Pear, Apple and Cheddar Pie
Sunday, 26th September 2010, 19:46

Previous PostRandom PostNext Post

Cheddar, as in cheddar cheese. Yup, sounds rather strange, or at least I thought so, but ever since my curiosity was piqued by "Pushing Daisies", I have wanted to give it a go.
Having never made a pie from scratch before, I was inspired by my new copy of "Grillhouse" by Ross Dobson, and produced this rustic (ugly) and super tasty pie using a pile of fruit bought during a bargain '$2 fill-a-bag with produce' clearance at Woollies.
Pear, Apple and Cheddar Pie
The cheese works surprisingly well, it blends into the crust and adds a salty and chewy contrast to the soft fruit. Choose a good aged or vintage cheddar, not too expensive, but not some cheap and plastic thing with no flavour. The pie should be served warm with some plain vanilla ice cream or thickened cream for simple and tasty comfort food.
Pear, Apple and Cheddar Pie

Pear, Apple and Cheddar Pie
Adapted from "Grillhouse" by Ross Dobson
Pear, Apple and Cheddar Pie
Shortcrust Pastry
A simple and quick pastry recipe, but I would recommend using a frozen pre-rolled shortcrust if pushed for time.
Pear, Apple and Cheddar Pie
Place 300g plain flour in a food processor, pulse together quickly with 2 tablespoons of caster sugar.
Drop 200g of chilled, cubed butter one piece at a time into the flour mixture until all added and pastry resembles wet sand. 2-3 tablespoons of iced water can be added to aid this process if required.
Tip out onto a floured surface and lightly knead into a ball.
Pear, Apple and Cheddar Pie
Cut in half, flatten each piece into a 10cm disc and wrap in cling wrap. Allow to cool in the fridge for at least half an hour and up to one day.
Pear, Apple and Cheddar Pie
Pear, Apple and Cheddar Pie
Remove from fridge half an hour before rolling.
To roll, place between 2 sheets of baking paper and roll out to at least 30cm or to fit a 23cm pie dish with some overhang.
Pear, Apple and Cheddar Pie
For the base piece, remove the top piece of paper and place in the pie dish with the bottom paper attached. Shape to dish and place in fridge while filling is prepared.
Pear, Apple and Cheddar Pie

Pear, Apple and Cheddar filling
You will need about 1.6k of fruit. I weighed out five Granny Smith apples and four green pears.
Pear, Apple and Cheddar Pie
To prepare, peel, core and chop into desired sized chunks, not too thin or it all turns to mush. Place in large bowl.
Pear, Apple and Cheddar Pie
Pear, Apple and Cheddar Pie
For flavour, add 165g caster sugar, 2 tablespoons lemon juice, ¼ teaspoon ground cinnamon, ¼ teaspoon all spice and 2 tablespoons of cornflour to the fruit.
Pear, Apple and Cheddar Pie
Pear, Apple and Cheddar Pie
Mix well with hands until well incorporated.

To assemble
Pile fruit high in centre of pie dish.
Pear, Apple and Cheddar Pie
Arrange thinly sliced pieces of aged cheddar cheese over the fruit, up to about 150g.
Pear, Apple and Cheddar Pie
Place top sheet of pastry gently over fruit, squeeze together edges and crimp with a fork.
Pear, Apple and Cheddar Pie
Brush one egg white over the top to make it brown up nicely and sprinkle with 2 tablespoons of caster sugar.
Pear, Apple and Cheddar Pie
Bake in an oven preheated to 220°c for 20mins, then reduce to 180°c and bake for a further 25mins. Allow to cool in pan for at least 30mins before serving with cream or ice cream.
Pear, Apple and Cheddar Pie
The pie is quite moist, possibly from the pears, so make sure to spoon out some of the saucy bit to mix in with the cream.
Pear, Apple and Cheddar Pie

1I would never have thought to add cheese to the fruit, it looks quite good though, I'll have to visit so you can make it for me.
by Karen Sergent on Sep 26th @ 08:02pm

2haha pushing daisies always makes me hungry! adding cheese sounds interesting but i reckon itd be a good match with pear
by chocolatesuze on Sep 27th @ 02:52am

3this pie was very very tasty :)
by jess on Nov 11th @ 09:26pm

Add Comment:
Please enter the word "chocolate" in the box above.

fivesquaremeals fivesquaremeals is the blog of Carly, a 20-something female living in the Macleay Valley on the mid north coast of NSW, Australia.
I love baking that begins with creaming butter and sugar, and eating anything with either bacon or custard. Or both :)
I enjoy going to good pubs, bakeries, food festivals, markets and regional shows.
Favourite Quotes:
"One must not let vanity overrule appetite"
"Donuts. Is there anything they can't do?"
Leave me a message, I'd love to hear from you!
more about fivesquaremeals


Blog Roll:


Follow Me:

I'm a Proud Member of The Daring Kitchen

This is a personal foodblog, please be advised that it does not aim to offer any serious form of advice, be it legal, medical or other.
It is intended for entertainment purposes only.
All opinions expressed and photos featured on the site are my own original work and remain the property of me.
fivesquaremeals promotes the responsible consumption of alcohol.

Site Map - Contact - Design & Development ©